Arrested Under 18? A Parent's Guide to Youth Justice Ontario

Navigating the legal system can be daunting for anyone, but when your child, under the age of 18, faces criminal charges in Ontario, the emotional and legal complexities can feel overwhelming. As a parent, your immediate instinct is to protect your child, and understanding the unique landscape of youth justice in Canada, governed by the Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA), is the first crucial step. This comprehensive guide aims to demystify the process, empower you with knowledge, and highlight the critical role of legal counsel in safeguarding your child's future.

The Immediate Aftermath: What Happens When a Youth is Arrested in Ontario?

The moment a young person (aged 12 to 17 inclusive) is arrested, a distinct set of rules and protections under the YCJA comes into play. Unlike the adult system, the YCJA emphasizes rehabilitation, reintegration, and accountability through measures proportionate to the seriousness of the offence and the young person's level of maturity. However, the initial steps can be confusing and stressful for both the youth and their parents.

Parental Notification: Your Right to Know

One of the most fundamental protections under the YCJA is the requirement for police to notify parents or guardians. Section 26 of the YCJA mandates that police must notify a parent or guardian as soon as possible when a young person is arrested or detained. This notification includes informing you of the reason for the arrest and where your child is being held. This is not merely a courtesy; it's a legal obligation designed to ensure that a responsible adult is aware of the situation and can provide support.

The Right to Counsel: A Non-Negotiable Protection

Upon arrest, your child has an absolute right to speak with a lawyer without delay and in private. This right is enshrined in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and reinforced by the YCJA. If your child cannot afford a lawyer, Legal Aid Ontario (LAO) provides services for youth dealing with criminal legal issues. It is paramount that your child exercises this right and does not answer any questions from the police until they have consulted with legal counsel. A lawyer can explain their rights, the charges, and the potential consequences, ensuring they do not inadvertently incriminate themselves.

Police Questioning and Statements: Special Protections for Youth

The YCJA provides additional safeguards regarding statements made by young persons to police. For a youth's statement to be admissible in court, several conditions must be met, as outlined in Section 146 of the YCJA:

•         The youth must be informed of their right to a lawyer and a parent/adult.

•         They must be given a reasonable opportunity to consult with a lawyer and a parent/adult.

•         The statement must be voluntary.

•         The youth must understand their rights and the nature of the statement.

It is crucial for parents to understand that while they have a right to be present during police questioning, their primary role is to support their child and ensure their rights are protected, not to advise on legal strategy. That role belongs to the lawyer. Never encourage your child to speak to the police without a lawyer present.

Understanding the Youth Criminal Justice Act (YCJA): A Different Philosophy

Passed in 2003, the YCJA replaced the Young Offenders Act (YOA) with a renewed focus on rehabilitation and reintegration, while still holding young persons accountable for their actions. The YCJA recognizes that young people are still developing and may not fully grasp the consequences of their actions in the same way adults do. Key principles of the YCJA include:

•         Accountability: Young persons must be held accountable, but in a manner proportionate to their maturity and the seriousness of the offence.

•         Rehabilitation and Reintegration: The system aims to address the underlying causes of a young person's offending behaviour and help them become law-abiding citizens.

•         Protection of the Public: This is achieved through measures that encourage rehabilitation and address risk factors.

•         Timely Intervention: Prompt responses to offending behaviour are encouraged.

•         Parental Involvement: Parents are recognized as having a crucial role in supporting their child through the justice process.

This philosophical shift means that the youth justice system often prioritizes alternatives to formal court proceedings and incarceration, especially for less serious offences.

Extrajudicial Measures (EJM): Keeping Youth Out of Court

For many first-time or less serious offences, the YCJA encourages the use of Extrajudicial Measures (EJMs). These are responses to offending behaviour that occurs outside of the formal court system. EJMs are designed to provide a timely and meaningful response to the offence, encourage accountability, and promote rehabilitation without the stigma of a criminal record. Examples of EJMs include:

•         Police Warnings: A formal warning from a police officer.

•         Police Cautions: A more serious warning, often delivered in the presence of a parent.

•         Referrals to Community Programs: Connecting the youth with counselling, anger management, or other support services.

•         Restorative Justice Programs: Mediated discussions between the youth, victim, and community members to repair harm.

•         Crown Caution: A formal caution from the Crown Attorney.

EJMs are often considered when the offence is not serious, the youth has no prior record, and they accept responsibility for their actions. Successful completion of an EJM means the youth avoids a formal court process and a criminal record. A youth criminal lawyer in Ontario can advocate for the use of EJMs, presenting your child's circumstances in full context to the Crown Attorney.

The Court Process: From First Appearance to Sentencing

If Extrajudicial Measures are not deemed appropriate, or if the offence is more serious, your child's case will proceed through the youth justice court system. This process involves several stages:

First Appearance

This is the initial court date where the charges are formally read, and the youth is given an opportunity to seek legal advice. It's also where decisions about bail (release from custody) are often made.

Disclosure

The Crown Attorney provides the defence with all the evidence they intend to use in the case. Your lawyer will review this material thoroughly to understand the strength of the prosecution's case and identify any potential defences.

Judicial Interim Release (Bail)

If your child is detained after arrest, a bail hearing will be held within 24 hours or as soon as possible. The YCJA has a presumption of release for youth, meaning the Crown must show why your child should not be released. Often, a youth can be released into the care of a responsible adult (usually a parent or close family member) who agrees to supervise them and ensure they attend court and follow conditions. Common bail conditions for youth in Ontario include:

•         Residing with a parent or guardian.

•         Attending school or work regularly.

•         Obeying a curfew.

•         No contact with co-accused or victims.

•         Staying away from specific locations.

•         Abstaining from drugs or alcohol.

Failing to comply with bail conditions can lead to further charges and detention, making it crucial to understand and adhere to them strictly.

Plea Bargaining and Resolution

Your lawyer will engage in discussions with the Crown Attorney to explore potential resolutions, which may include pleading guilty to a lesser charge or agreeing to certain conditions in exchange for a reduced sentence. This is a critical stage where legal representation can significantly impact the outcome.

Trial

If a resolution cannot be reached, the case will proceed to trial, where the Crown must prove the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. Youth trials are generally less formal than adult trials, but the principles of justice remain the same.

Sentencing

If a youth is found guilty or pleads guilty, the court will impose a sentence. The YCJA offers a range of sentencing options, always with the principles of rehabilitation and reintegration in mind. These can include:

•         Absolute Discharge: No finding of guilt, no record.

•         Conditional Discharge: Conditions are imposed; if met, no record.

•         Probation: Supervision by a youth probation officer with specific conditions.

•         Fines: Monetary penalties.

•         Community Service: Performing unpaid work for the benefit of the community.

•         Custody and Supervision Order: A period of detention followed by a period of supervision in the community. Custody is generally a last resort for youth.

Youth Records: The Myth of the Clean Slate" at 18.

Many parents mistakenly believe that a youth criminal record automatically disappears when their child turns 18. This is a dangerous misconception. While the YCJA does provide for specific rules regarding the privacy and disclosure of youth records, they do not simply vanish. Instead, they are subject to access periods.

During an access period, a youth record can still be accessed by certain individuals and agencies, such as police, Crown attorneys, and courts, for specific purposes. The length of the access period depends on the severity of the offence and the disposition (sentence) received. For example, a record for a less serious offence resulting in a discharge might have a shorter access period than a record for a more serious offence resulting in a custody sentence. If a young person commits another offence as an adult before the access period for their youth record expires, the youth record can become part of their adult criminal record, with significant long-term consequences.

This is why it is crucial to understand that even a youth record can have serious implications for future employment, travel, and educational opportunities. A skilled youth criminal lawyer can work to minimize the impact of a youth record, and in some cases, explore options for early termination of access periods or sealing of records, though these are complex legal processes.

The Critical Role of an Youth Criminal Lawyer

When your child is arrested, the natural inclination might be to seek legal advice from any criminal lawyer. However, the youth justice system is a distinct area of law, distinct from the adult system. A youth criminal lawyer in Ontario possesses a deep understanding of the YCJA, its unique principles, procedures, and sentencing options. They are adept at navigating the nuances of youth court, advocating for Extrajudicial Measures, and protecting your child's rights at every stage.

Here's why legal counsel is indispensable:

•         Understanding the YCJA: A lawyer experienced in youth justice knows the intricacies of the Act, including the specific protections afforded to young persons regarding statements, bail, and sentencing.

•         Advocacy for EJMs: They can effectively negotiate with the police and Crown Attorney for Extrajudicial Measures, potentially diverting your child from the formal court system entirely.

•         Protecting Rights During Interrogation: They ensure your child's right to silence and right to counsel are upheld, preventing self-incrimination.

•         Navigating Bail Hearings: They can present a compelling case for your child's release, often securing release into parental care with reasonable conditions.

•         Minimizing Record Impact: They understand the complexities of youth records and can work to achieve outcomes that minimize long-term consequences.

•         Guidance and Support: Beyond legal strategy, they provide invaluable guidance and emotional support to both the youth and their family throughout a challenging process.

Choosing a lawyer who regularly practices in youth court is not just an advantage; it is a necessity for the appropriate outcome for your child.

Conclusion: Empowering Parents Through Knowledge and Action

An arrest can be a terrifying experience for any young person and their family. However, understanding the Youth Criminal Justice Act and the specific protections it offers can empower parents to act decisively and effectively. The youth justice system in Ontario is designed with rehabilitation and reintegration in mind, but navigating its complexities requires careful legal guidance. By securing legal representation from a youth criminal lawyer in Ontario, you are not only protecting your child's immediate future but also investing in their long-term well-being and ability to move forward positively. If your child has been arrested under 18, do not delay. Seek legal advice immediately to ensure their rights are protected and to explore every available option.

https://ourlawservices.com/blog/first-time-offender-guide-mississauga-and-the-peel-region

DISCLAIMER: The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. No attorney-client relationship is established through this writing. You should consult with a qualified attorney for advice tailored to your specific situation. The lawyer and their firm disclaim any liability arising from reliance on this blog or any other content on this website.

Questions about this topic? See our page on youth criminal charges in Mississauga, or call (289) 652-0529.